🏠 Home
AQA A-Level Economics ยท Theme 4

Measures of
Development

GDP per capita, HDI, poverty measures, SDGs and alternative indicators

๐Ÿ“˜ 10 slides + 8 questions โฑ 20 min ๐ŸŽฏ Theme 4: Global Perspective
Learning Objectives

By the end of this lesson you will be able toโ€ฆ

Explain the strengths and weaknesses of GDP per capita as a measure of development
Calculate and interpret the Human Development Index (HDI) and explain why it improves on GDP
Distinguish absolute poverty from relative poverty and evaluate measures of each
Describe the Sustainable Development Goals and alternative indicators of wellbeing beyond income
Income Measures

GDP Per Capita โ€” Strengths and Limitations

STRENGTHS
Widely available โ€” all countries measure it; comparable internationally; correlates well with life expectancy, education, and other outcomes; useful for tracking growth over time; PPP-adjusted GDP corrects for price level differences across countries.
2024 BENCHMARKS
High income: >$13,846/year (World Bank). Upper-middle: $4,466โ€“$13,845. Lower-middle: $1,136โ€“$4,465. Low income: <$1,136. UK: ~$46,000. USA: ~$76,000. Bangladesh: ~$2,700. Malawi: ~$630. These PPP-adjusted figures are the AQA standard reference.
LIMITATIONS
Ignores distribution: Saudi Arabia and Botswana have similar GDP/capita but very different inequality. Ignores non-market activity: childcare, subsistence farming, voluntary work. Excludes environmental degradation (extraction of natural resources adds to GDP). Ignores access to public services: Cuba has low GDP/capita but high life expectancy. Hides informal economy: large in developing countries, not captured in GDP.
GDP PARADOXES
Paradox of GDP: a car crash increases GDP (medical care, car repair). Oil spill increases GDP (cleanup costs). Parent doing childcare at home = zero GDP; paying a childminder = GDP. GDP measures activity, not welfare. Easterlin Paradox: within countries, richer people are happier; but richer countries are not proportionately happier โ€” suggests GDP misses key welfare drivers above a threshold.
Multi-Dimensional Measure

Human Development Index (HDI)

HDI โ€” Three Dimensions
Created by UNDP (1990), designed by Amartya Sen and Mahbub ul Haq. Combines three indicators into a single composite score (0โ€“1): Health (life expectancy), Education (mean and expected years of schooling), Income (GNI per capita PPP). No single dimension is all of development.
๐Ÿฅ
HEALTH
Life expectancy at birth
๐Ÿ“š
EDUCATION
Mean + expected years of schooling
๐Ÿ’ฐ
INCOME
GNI per capita (PPP)
COUNTRY EXAMPLES (2023)
Norway ๐Ÿ‡ณ๐Ÿ‡ด: 0.966 (1st). UK ๐Ÿ‡ฌ๐Ÿ‡ง: 0.940 (15th). China ๐Ÿ‡จ๐Ÿ‡ณ: 0.788 (75th). India ๐Ÿ‡ฎ๐Ÿ‡ณ: 0.644 (134th). Nigeria ๐Ÿ‡ณ๐Ÿ‡ฌ: 0.535 (163rd). Niger ๐Ÿ‡ณ๐Ÿ‡ช: 0.394 (189th, last).
LIMITATIONS OF HDI
Ignores inequality within countries (UK and South Africa have similar HDI but very different distributions); doesn't capture human rights, political freedom, sustainability; arbitrary weighting (equal weights for three dimensions); doesn't include gender, environmental, or subjective wellbeing measures. The UNDP now supplements HDI with additional indices.
HDI vs GDP ANOMALIES
Cuba: low GDP/capita (~$9k) but high HDI (0.764) โ€” public healthcare and education. Saudi Arabia: high GDP/capita (~$54k) but lower HDI relative to income (gender inequality in education/employment). Sri Lanka: middle income but high HDI โ€” early investment in health and education. Anomalies reveal what income alone misses.
Beyond Standard HDI

Inequality-Adjusted HDI & Gender Development

INEQUALITY-ADJUSTED HDI (IHDI)
Discounts HDI by how unequally each dimension is distributed within the country. A perfectly equal country loses nothing. Unequal countries see large "losses." South Africa: HDI 0.713 but IHDI falls to 0.468 (34% loss โ€” one of the highest in the world). Brazil: 30% loss. UK: ~7% loss. The "loss" represents welfare destroyed by inequality.
GENDER DEVELOPMENT INDEX (GDI)
Compares HDI calculated separately for women and men. Ratio close to 1 = gender equality. Most LDCs show female HDI significantly lower than male โ€” reflected in lower female life expectancy in some countries, lower education enrolment, lower labour force participation. GDI highlights that "average" HDI hides systematic female disadvantage.
MULTIDIMENSIONAL POVERTY INDEX (MPI)
Oxford Poverty and Human Development Initiative (OPHI): poverty measured across 10 indicators in health, education, and living standards. Someone is "multidimensionally poor" if deprived in โ‰ฅ30% of weighted indicators. More nuanced than income threshold: ~1.1 billion people in acute multidimensional poverty globally (vs ~700m below $2.15/day line). India has made remarkable MPI progress: ~415m lifted out of MPI poverty (2005โ€“2021).
PLANETARY PRESSURES-ADJUSTED HDI
New UNDP measure: discounts HDI by each country's carbon emissions and material footprint. High-HDI, high-emission countries fall dramatically. Norway (HDI 0.966) falls to 0.898 when adjusted for planetary pressures. Qatar (0.855) falls to 0.575 โ€” heavy carbon economy. Forces recognition that human development sustainability matters, not just current welfare.
Poverty Measurement

Absolute vs Relative Poverty

Absolute Poverty
Living below a fixed minimum threshold needed for basic survival โ€” food, shelter, water. World Bank: $2.15/day (2022 update, PPP-adjusted). 700m people globally below this line (~9% of world population). Progress: 2bn lived below $1.90/day in 1990 โ†’ 700m today. Extreme poverty dramatically reduced, mainly due to China and East Asia.
RELATIVE POVERTY
Living below a threshold defined relative to the society you live in. EU/UK definition: household income below 60% of median national income. UK 2023: ~22% of population (14.4m) in relative poverty. Relative poverty persists even in rich countries โ€” it captures social exclusion and inability to participate in the norms of one's society.
KEY DISTINCTION
Absolute poverty: can in theory be eliminated by economic growth alone. Relative poverty: cannot be eliminated by growth if distribution stays the same โ€” indeed relative poverty can rise even as absolute poverty falls. UK: absolute poverty fell post-2000 but relative poverty remained high. Policy must address both dimensions.
Global Framework

Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)

WHAT ARE THE SDGs?
17 goals adopted by all 193 UN member states in 2015, to be achieved by 2030. Successor to Millennium Development Goals (MDGs, 2000โ€“2015). Broadened from poverty/health focus to include: climate action (13), inequality (10), sustainable cities (11), gender equality (5), clean energy (7), economic growth and decent work (8), zero hunger (2).
PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
MDGs largely achieved: child mortality halved; maternal mortality fell 44%; extreme poverty halved; primary school completion near universal. SDGs: COVID-19 reversed 5 years of progress. UN (2023): only 15% of 169 SDG targets on track; 37% stagnating; 48% seriously off track. Climate and biodiversity SDGs furthest behind.
ALTERNATIVE INDICATORS
Genuine Progress Indicator (GPI): adjusts GDP for inequality, crime, pollution, voluntary work, leisure. Physical Quality of Life Index (PQLI): literacy, infant mortality, life expectancy. Gross National Happiness (Bhutan): governance, time use, culture, ecology, living standards, psychological wellbeing, health, education, community vitality.
EVALUATION FOR AQA
No single measure of development is perfect โ€” AQA wants you to argue that a combination of indicators is needed. Key evaluations: (1) Trade-off between comprehensiveness and measurability. (2) Country context matters โ€” what works for UK doesn't work for Ethiopia. (3) Amartya Sen's "capability approach": focus on what people can do and be, not just income.
Question 1 of 8
Which of the following is NOT captured by GDP per capita as a measure of development?
A
The total value of goods and services produced in the economy in a year
B
The distribution of income across different groups in society
C
The size of the traded sector relative to total output
D
The value of marketed goods compared to previous years
Answer ยท Question 1
Which of the following is NOT captured by GDP per capita as a measure of development?
A
The total value of goods and services produced in the economy in a year
B
The distribution of income across different groups in society
C
The size of the traded sector relative to total output
D
The value of marketed goods compared to previous years
Correct: B. GDP per capita is a mean โ€” it says nothing about distribution. A country with GDP/capita of $10,000 could have extreme inequality (a few billionaires and masses in poverty) or near-perfect equality. This is the most important limitation of GDP as a development measure. South Africa's GDP/capita of ~$6,500 is respectable for a developing country but its Gini coefficient of 0.63 (one of the world's highest) means much of the population lives in severe poverty.
Question 2 of 8
The Human Development Index (HDI) combines which three dimensions?
A
GDP growth rate, employment rate, and inflation rate
B
Life expectancy, education (years of schooling), and income (GNI per capita)
C
Poverty rate, inequality (Gini), and environmental quality
D
GDP, trade balance, and government debt as a percentage of GDP
Answer ยท Question 2
The Human Development Index (HDI) combines which three dimensions?
A
GDP growth rate, employment rate, and inflation rate
B
Life expectancy, education (years of schooling), and income (GNI per capita)
C
Poverty rate, inequality (Gini), and environmental quality
D
GDP, trade balance, and government debt as a percentage of GDP
Correct: B. The HDI specifically measures: (1) Health โ€” life expectancy at birth; (2) Education โ€” mean years of schooling (adults) and expected years of schooling (children); (3) Standard of living โ€” GNI per capita (PPP). Developed by Mahbub ul Haq and Amartya Sen for UNDP in 1990. The idea was that human development goes beyond income โ€” a long, educated, and decent-income life is the goal, not income alone.
Question 3 of 8
Cuba has a relatively low GDP per capita but a relatively high HDI. This anomaly is best explained by:
A
Cuba's large black market economy that is not captured by official GDP statistics
B
Cuba's strong public investment in universal healthcare and education producing high life expectancy and literacy despite low income
C
Cuba receives more foreign aid per capita than any other developing country
D
HDI is measured at purchasing power parity, which inflates Cuba's score relative to its nominal GDP
Answer ยท Question 3
Cuba has a relatively low GDP per capita but a relatively high HDI. This anomaly is best explained by:
A
Cuba's large black market economy that is not captured by official GDP statistics
B
Cuba's strong public investment in universal healthcare and education producing high life expectancy and literacy despite low income
C
Cuba receives more foreign aid per capita than any other developing country
D
HDI is measured at purchasing power parity, which inflates Cuba's score relative to its nominal GDP
Correct: B. Cuba is the classic example of high human development relative to income. The Cuban government prioritised universal free healthcare (doctors per capita rivals OECD countries) and free education to university level since 1959. Result: life expectancy ~79 years (close to UK); adult literacy ~99%; HDI 0.764 (high human development category). This shows that how income is allocated matters as much as the level โ€” public services can substitute for private income.
Question 4 of 8
Relative poverty in the UK is typically defined as:
A
Living below the World Bank's international poverty line of $2.15 per day (PPP)
B
Being unable to afford any items beyond basic necessities such as food and shelter
C
Living in a household with income below 60% of median household income
D
Having a household net worth in the bottom 10% of the wealth distribution
Answer ยท Question 4
Relative poverty in the UK is typically defined as:
A
Living below the World Bank's international poverty line of $2.15 per day (PPP)
B
Being unable to afford any items beyond basic necessities such as food and shelter
C
Living in a household with income below 60% of median household income
D
Having a household net worth in the bottom 10% of the wealth distribution
Correct: C. The EU/UK standard definition: relative poverty = income below 60% of median national household income (after housing costs). In 2023, UK median household income โ‰ˆ ยฃ36,400 (before housing costs); 60% threshold = ~ยฃ21,840. About 22% of UK households (~14.4m people including 4.3m children) fall below this line. This definition links poverty to social norms โ€” it's about being unable to participate in the typical life of your society, not just bare survival.
Question 5 of 8
The Inequality-Adjusted HDI (IHDI) differs from the standard HDI because it:
A
Adds a fourth dimension covering political freedom and civil liberties
B
Discounts the HDI score to reflect how unequally each dimension is distributed within the country
C
Adjusts HDI for environmental sustainability by penalising high-carbon economies
D
Uses purchasing power parity to correct for cost-of-living differences between countries
Answer ยท Question 5
The Inequality-Adjusted HDI (IHDI) differs from the standard HDI because it:
A
Adds a fourth dimension covering political freedom and civil liberties
B
Discounts the HDI score to reflect how unequally each dimension is distributed within the country
C
Adjusts HDI for environmental sustainability by penalising high-carbon economies
D
Uses purchasing power parity to correct for cost-of-living differences between countries
Correct: B. The IHDI applies an "inequality discount" to each of the three HDI dimensions. The more unequal the distribution of health, education, or income within a country, the larger the discount. South Africa's HDI (0.713) falls to IHDI 0.468 โ€” a 34% loss due to extreme inequality in health, education, and income. Brazil loses ~30%. This makes IHDI a much better measure of average human development actually experienced across the population.
Question 6 of 8
The Easterlin Paradox refers to the finding that:
A
Countries with higher inequality always have lower happiness despite higher GDP
B
Within a country richer people report higher happiness, but richer countries are not systematically happier than poorer ones
C
Economic growth always improves subjective wellbeing in developing countries but not in developed ones
D
Countries that grow faster experience more inequality and less happiness
Answer ยท Question 6
The Easterlin Paradox refers to the finding that:
A
Countries with higher inequality always have lower happiness despite higher GDP
B
Within a country richer people report higher happiness, but richer countries are not systematically happier than poorer ones
C
Economic growth always improves subjective wellbeing in developing countries but not in developed ones
D
Countries that grow faster experience more inequality and less happiness
Correct: B. Richard Easterlin (1974) found: within a country at a given time, higher income correlates with higher self-reported happiness. But over time, as countries grow richer, average happiness doesn't rise proportionately. This suggests relative income (status, comparison) matters more than absolute income beyond a threshold. It supports using measures beyond GDP โ€” wellbeing is about more than income, especially once basic needs are met. The World Happiness Report finds Finland consistently happiest, not the richest countries.
Question 7 of 8
Which of the following is a key advantage of the Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI) over the World Bank's $2.15/day income line?
A
The MPI is simpler to calculate and requires less data than the income poverty line
B
It captures deprivation across multiple dimensions (health, education, living standards) rather than income alone
C
The MPI adjusts for purchasing power parity while the income line does not
D
It includes political and civil rights dimensions that the income line ignores
Answer ยท Question 7
Which of the following is a key advantage of the Multidimensional Poverty Index (MPI) over the World Bank's $2.15/day income line?
A
The MPI is simpler to calculate and requires less data than the income poverty line
B
It captures deprivation across multiple dimensions (health, education, living standards) rather than income alone
C
The MPI adjusts for purchasing power parity while the income line does not
D
It includes political and civil rights dimensions that the income line ignores
Correct: B. The MPI measures deprivation across 10 indicators in health (nutrition, child mortality), education (years of schooling, school attendance), and living standards (cooking fuel, sanitation, drinking water, electricity, housing, assets). Someone may have $2.15/day but lack clean water, adequate schooling, or healthcare โ€” the income line misses this. Conversely, some may have income above the threshold but still be poor in other dimensions. The MPI gives a richer picture of poverty's nature and location.
Question 8 of 8
According to UN progress reports (2023), what proportion of the 169 SDG targets are approximately on track to be met by 2030?
A
About 70โ€“80%, suggesting the SDGs are broadly succeeding
B
About 50%, with the poorest countries falling furthest behind
C
About 15%, with COVID-19 having reversed several years of progress
D
Almost none โ€” all targets have been abandoned since the pandemic
Answer ยท Question 8
According to UN progress reports (2023), what proportion of the 169 SDG targets are approximately on track to be met by 2030?
A
About 70โ€“80%, suggesting the SDGs are broadly succeeding
B
About 50%, with the poorest countries falling furthest behind
C
About 15%, with COVID-19 having reversed several years of progress
D
Almost none โ€” all targets have been abandoned since the pandemic
Correct: C. The UN's 2023 SDG Progress Report was stark: only ~15% of targets on track; 37% showing moderate progress or stagnation; 48% seriously off-track or regressing. COVID-19 reversed years of progress on poverty, health, and education. Climate and biodiversity goals are furthest behind. The MDGs (2000โ€“2015) were more successful partly because they were fewer, more focused, and had clearer targets. The breadth of the SDGs and inadequate financing make them harder to achieve.
๐ŸŽ“

Lesson Complete

You've covered GDP per capita (strengths and limitations), HDI (three dimensions, country examples, anomalies), inequality-adjusted HDI, absolute vs relative poverty, the Multidimensional Poverty Index, the Sustainable Development Goals, and alternative wellbeing measures.

โ† Economics Home All Lessons